Skip to content
Point Culture UK

A United Ireland Plebiscite Should Not Transform Into 'Another Brexit', Experts Caution

A decade after the UK entered into a hasty public vote that polarised the nation and triggered disorder, a caution comes from beyond the Irish Sea: it may occur once more.

The government and citizens drifted into Brexit and the identical might transpire with a referendum on a unified Ireland, sparking disturbances for which nobody is ready.

That conveys the caution from two respected journalists from each side of the Irish border who have teamed up to scrutinise the pros and cons of Northern Ireland exiting the UK to create a fresh nation with the Republic of Ireland.

Administrative Institutions Unprepared

Fintan O’Toole and Sam McBride, have found that the political establishments in Ireland and Britain are extremely ill-prepared for a possibly tense and seismic referendum.

"The lesson of Brexit remains unheeded, which is that events can arise suddenly and can build support rapidly," O’Toole remarked. "In my opinion that the institutional structure of our archipelago remains highly fragile."

Released Volume Aims to Stir Debate

The duo have analysed the governmental, economic and societal rationales for any governmental shift in a book, For and Against a United Ireland, issued by the Irish Royal Irish Academy.

They seek to stir debate on the matter with a roadshow of public talks that will bring them to Westminster soon.

"What troubles everybody, or must worry all involved, is the Brexit referendum of 2016," commented the analyst.

"We must avoid a referendum on a binary, vague proposition whose consequences have not been clarified because then you end up with an highly split population where those defeated are unable to accept losing and the people who have won lack clarity quite what it is that they have won."

Legal Framework

Under the Good Friday agreement, the Northern Ireland official should call a referendum on Irish unification if it is indicated that a most voters would support.

Nationalist parties and other nationalists claim such a time is looming, and a organisation named Ireland’s Future has rallied support, but both governments and pro-UK factions downplay the possibility, resulting in ambiguity whether or when there could be a national vote.

Insufficient Serious Debate

Political rhetoric for and against unity has masked the shortage of substantive discussion, noted McBride.

"People tend to be for or against the concept but the detailed consideration which might go beyond that to realise it has largely not occurred. Much has taken place in academia but hardly any elected officials or campaigners seek to involve themselves even with the fundamentals. To illustrate, what sort of state would you want? Centralised? Federal?"

Book's Approach

In the publication, neither author supports unification or the existing arrangement. Both composes two articles that seek impartiality in presenting the case for a unified Ireland and the case against, marshalling economic and social figures, past examples and governmental frameworks.

Arguments range over identity markers, levies, medical care, pensions, sovereign debt obligations and the risk of pro-UK militancy. The aim is to inform and encourage conversation.

"There's huge interest in the issue but there hasn't quite been a discussion," stated O’Toole. "Debate indicates an acceptance of the idea that there might be reasonable perspectives on each side."

Dual Referendums

A public vote in Northern Ireland would additionally cause one in the republic, where voters say they support unification but oppose greater financial contributions or implementing a new flag to recognise pro-UK communities' British identity.

"Policymakers in Ireland does need to determine what the proposal from Irish nationalism is aside from just declaring: 'We want a unified Ireland and we welcome you'," stated the commentator.

Likelihood of Referendum

McBride believes a national vote in his lifetime is possible and that it may take place suddenly. "It is possible just a mad or a poor or a negligent secretary of state who declares: 'Let's just do this and get it out of the way.'"

Both nationalists and unionists have reasonable, valid points, he said. "Somebody will win here and somebody will eventually not succeed but each side has has something to gain from the alternative positions."

Appeal for Broader Dialogue

Westminster needed to engage with the discussion, stated the analyst. "This concerns your state. It's a British issue just as much as it is an Irish question."

Written by

Colin Higgins

A London-based cultural critic and arts journalist with a passion for uncovering emerging creative voices.

Point Culture UK

Type to search articles.